THE CULT OF PSYCHOLOGICAL COERCION
By Synthia Esther
I wondered what would prompt a person to become involved with PSI large group awareness training (LGAT), and similar seminars. I became concerned when I found out a Christian acquaintance named Anna (not her real name), had spent thousands of dollars to attend such seminars. After reading some of the information, forums and blogs on Ripoff Report.com concerning EST and Werner Erhard, and the Skeptic's Dictionary - PSI Seminars (just to name a few), I found out the emotional and physical trauma as well as psychological harm people have suffered from participating in such programs. Many people have spent close to $10,000.00 just to be subjected to an abusive means of brainwashing and coercion.I learned the seminar's themselves were connected with books, material, and people who were noted new age followers (also called wave or new thought believers), with deep roots in Eastern philosophies. Shortly after my research I warned Anna of my findings, mailing her the copied documentation which equaled a small telephone book in size. Anna's response, “They represent themselves as Christian, and I am having the time of my life!”
Now months latter Anna admitted they had displayed on a sale table a book about Buddhism along with other books authored by the company president, who claimed he was a Christian. There are many world spiritual leaders that have no objection to one using the words “God” or “Christ,” because they believe the title will lead one to their God, or believe many paths lead to the same God. There is only one true God, and his name is Jesus Christ, the Messiah. Matthew 7:13, “Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it.”
Anna, on repeated occasions had self appointed me as her spiritual mentor, having repeatedly requested to let her know if I felt she was ever going astray from Biblical scripture. After this incident and contradiction, I distanced myself from the friendship placing Anna in God's hands. During a recent college social psychology class I took self-esteem and self efficacy was a topic covered in depth. Rhodes & Wood, 1992, confirmed people with low self-esteem are often slow to comprehend a message and therefore hard to persuade. Those with high self-esteem may comprehend yet remain confident of their own opinions, with people of moderate self-esteem being the easiest to influence. I would describe Anna's self esteem traits as falling into the moderate range.
The next week while wearing a blue and silver cross Anna had once given me as a gift, I caught a glimpse of its reflection in the bathroom mirror as I was brushing my teeth. God spoke to my spirit, “The cross is the answer to Anna's problems...it is the solution and answer to all of humanities problems as well. The price has already been paid.” Jesus Christ is the only savior in the world who died on a cross. His death and resurrection not only paid for humanities salvations plan, it covers our healing, validation, self-worth, and any other personal problem we may encounter in life. God's Holy Spirit inspired training course is also outlined within His word – the Holy Bible, and it last from the cradle to the grave.
I did not want to take the time to research leadership experimental, personal development companies, sensitivity training, psycho heresy, visualization, hypnotic - trance occult practices, and the self mastery seminars they promote, however, God was prompting me to do otherwise. Reflecting on Jonah's plight of ending up in the belly of a whale when not following God's will, I began that very night dedicated to researching what Philip Cushman referred to as “mass marathon trainings”.
After only three hours of delving into the PSI/EST/ LGAT psycho heresy subject matter I realized the infiltration of new age belief systems had grown exponentially comprising a global network of spiritual influence and followers within the last decade. My first personal experience with Eastern New Age beliefs, visualization, the occult and channeled spirits, came about when I purchased a book called “Seth Speaks,” at a discount book store while on an excursion in Panama City Beach, Florida. The store was about to close when we walked in the door. I grabbed a few books at random, the yellow hard back “Seth Speaks” book attracted my attention, and I paid for my selections.
At the time, I did not know “Seth Speaks” was a spirit speaking through Jane Roberts with the spirit's messages written down by her husband. Out of curiosity I tried the relaxing visualization technique as instructed in the book, thinking it would be harmless, and to my surprise I too heard from a spirit who began to talk to me. Introducing himself by name, offering words of wisdom and a safe heaven in which to rest, explore, learn, be cared for and loved.
He had white hair, wore a long white garment with a tied sash at the waist. He walked with me along the beach shore, and spoke positive thoughts of personal guidance, wisdom, peace and love. What became apparently real within my spirit is how my experimental visualization technique created a wise man who took on a life and spirit of his own. He told me his age, which was almost 2000 years old, and conversed at great lengths. Visualization is real, powerful and convincing. I can see how those who open themselves up to such practices believe in what they preach, and preach what they believe. I gave my mother the illustration that it was like visually holding an ice cream cone but the difference was you could actually taste the ice cream.
I destroyed and trashed the book (I now know I should have burned it), mother and I prayed, and I rebuked the spirit that attempted to help and guide me. The only voice I want to hear from is the voice of the Holy Spirit. Satan is real and his demons are ready, willing and able to appear as anyone, or anything your heart desires. When you open the door to the occult Satan has a personal invitation to “come right in”. Visualization techniques leave the door wide open.
“THE LAW OF ATTRACTION WORKS”
The law of attraction works...and Satan is behind the attraction! Satanic forces masquerade as beings of light, angels, deceased loved ones, spirit guides, fairy's, rocks that will talk to you, and power from on high. They can speak through your dog, as David Berkowitz* has claimed, and any thing else you allow yourself to open your spirit up to believe and thus receive.
This includes the power of suggestion placed within your mind by another human being. Visualization leads to altered trance states of consciousness and has been used by shamans for thousands of years. You can be hypnotized and not even know it. Check out Derren Browns “youtube” demonstrations on such topics as Subliminal Minds, Trains of Thought, and NLP – Neuro Linguistic Programing topics if you desire a presentation of cause and effect.
A few years later I continued my studies in New York where I was introduced to Napoleon Hill's book, “Think And Grow Rich”, which was required reading in my broadcast and commercial class. At the end of the course the instructor took pictures of each student as if they were appearing in a national television commercial. While each student held up an object, such as toothpaste we were told to smile for the camera. Many actors and actresses carried index cards with positive affirmations and would read them while riding the subways.
During this time I also came in contact with Ron L. Hubbard's Scientology converts, most actors and actresses themselves who manned card tables set up with the Dyanetic Bible proudly displayed and free phamlets out lining and promoting their “clearing” program. One table set up was positioned right outside an office high rise that was also the address of a well known casting director.
The information pamphlet was unlike anything I had ever read before, and when the opportunity to purchase a used copy of Dyanetics presented itself, I bought the large book with its own dictionary of terms and definitions. Just reading the dictionary confirms Hubbard's writing background as sci fi author, with Battlefield Earth (1982), becoming a New York Times best seller. Firm in my spiritual convections and beliefs, I had no intention of converting, but like the saying goes, inquiring minds want to know. Scientology clearing methods are often compared to PSI/EST methods of psychological mind cleansing.
Little did I know years later I would be writing about my New Age experiences in an article pertaining to PSI/EST seminars. God's provedental life training programs are on going lasting from the cradle to the grave, especially when we have a generational background of spiritually dedicated God fearing parents or grandparents. As I can personally attest to, Biblical scripture confirming generational blessings and curses are as real as the blood within our veins (reference article: Addiction Definition and Hypothesis).
The new age belief system incorporates elements from all the major world religions with insights and influences from spiritualism, Buddhism, Hinduism, Shamanism, Sufism, Taoism and Neo-Paganism. Neo-Paganism being defined as pre-Christian pagan religions, with some additions from contemporary religious thinkers. Again the common thread that all paths to God are one and the same.
As for mass marathon large group awareness training (LGAT), and EST/PSI seminars, my research leads me to conclude that “all” incorporate some form of brainwashing training methods, occult visualization, hypnosis and trance disciplines, unethical psychological and emotional abuse, coercive hard sell business and marketing techniques, detrimental and harmful psychological medical practices, all in the guise of humanitarian efforts, human potential, success and mastery programs.
Many such PSI -LGAT companies also claim to be Christian in scope, deed and action. Author Russ Wise, Christian Information Ministries (CIM), under Transformational Seminars, “The Loss Of Mental Health” , 6/10/2003, states, “New Age trainers have cleverly disguised their agenda in the marketplace. Their goal is to bring about a paradigm shift, a total realignment of humanity from a Judeo-Christian world view to one that is metaphysical (the belief that the mind has power to influence forces within the universe which can change material reality at its root).
He continues, “Some are blatantly new age in their approach while others attempt to mask their underlying philosophy and draw upon a Christian label for credibility. The challenge for the Christian, or for that matter, anyone – secular or otherwise, is to determine whether a given seminar would be psychologically healthy for them to pursue.” Wise concludes, “ In this author's opinion, after twenty-eight years of observation, there is not one seminar that would meet the criteria needed to allow any degree of peace.”
Wise speaks wisely as he goes onto explain the seminar recruit is met with the non-telling phrase, “I can't tell you about it. You'll just have to come and experience it for yourself. It changed my life, I just can't describe it! Then the sells pitch begins!” The brochure usually mentions that you are about to begin an adventure into better understanding yourself. It's experimental! Its a life changing experience ... Wise states that the participants are, in most cases totally unaware that they will participate in exercises of a hypnotic or assaultive character designed to strip away their Judeo-Christian world view and replace it with an essentially Eastern mystical one.
He states, “The psycho-spiritual conversion that the trainee experiences during the seminar is destined to usurp any prior religious or spiritual experience the individual may have had. The reality is this – this trainee has become fully actualized. He or she has now become the center of his or her universe. In essence, they have given themselves permission to live life on their own terms. They no longer pay attention to an authority beyond themselves. They become self-serving, self-focused, and ultimately self-defeating.”
Wise continues to expound, “There are brave souls among us! They have withstood the pains of the seminar and survived to render aide. They, in short, are the ones who have filled-in the blank spaces the brochure adeptly left out. Mark Brewer, a writer for “Psychology Today,” is one of the braves souls. He attended Est and wrote about his experience. Mark gives an in-depth look at the seminar and reveals to the reader the underlying “truth” of Est.” You are perfect the way you are! Werner Erhard gave greater understanding of this idea with the following statement, “Sometimes people get the notion that the purpose of “Est” is to make you better. It is not. I happen to think you are perfect exactly the way you are”.
To arrive at this profound understanding the participant is first told, “We're gonna throw away your whole belief system. We're gonna tear you down and put you back together.” In essence the trainer is given the responsibility to cajole the participants to the point that they no longer have a sense of individuality, but are left with a debilitating sense of worthlessness. However, the sense of worthlessness is only temporary.
The trainer is then responsible for restoring the individual to a sense of empowerment, wholeness, and potential to conquer. In effect, what happens is a psychological conversion experience. Some liken this conversion experience to that of being reborn – as a Christian might view it. However, this conversion is not Scripturally supported. It is rooted in a psycho-spiritual realm that is bathed in deception.
BRAINWASHING
The word brainwashing came to be used in the United States in an effort to explain why, compared to earlier wars, a relatively high percentage of American GI's defected to the Communists after becoming prisoners of war in Korea. Later analysis determined that some of the primary methologies employed on them during their imprisonment included sleep deprivation and other intense psychological manipulations designed to break down the autonomy of individuals. These same methods are used, as witnesses attest to, within PSI/EST seminars. Lack of sleep, inadequate food breaks, emotional unrest and exhaustion, are common problems voiced by many participants in attendance.
ROBERT JAY LIFTON, MD – AMERICAN PSYCIATRIST AND AUTHOR
Robert Lifton, MD, is known for his studies and expertise pertaining to the psychological causes and effects of war and political violence and for his theory of thought reform. In 2006, Lifton appeared with fellow psychiatrist Peter A. Olsson on the History Channel in a documentary of Cults, titled “Decoding The Past”. Lifton outlines 8 characteristics used in brainwashing techniques. I have included a summary of each of the characteristics according to his findings.
- Milieu Control – Control of information and communication.
- Mystical Manipulation – Personal manipulation by a person or organization that creates a mystique around themselves, making them appear to have knowledge or a unique position/relationship to God.
- Demand For Purity – Disowning anything that makes life complicated, seeking the pure truth.
- Cult Confession – Purging of wrong thoughts, deeds, and/or actions (confession sessions).
- Sacred Science – Their truth is the truth. There is no other truth. Only their truth works, prevails, is tested, and achieved.
- Load The Language – The use of thought terminating cliches.
- Doctrine Over Person – Subordination of human experience to doctrine. They are right....you are always wrong, unless of course you agree with their doctrine.
- Dispensing Of Existence – The organization has all rights because they know what is right. If you do not agree with the organization your rights are terminated, or you are made to believe you don't have a right to life.
MARGARET SINGER AUTHOR OF THE BOOK, “CULTS IN THE MIDST”
Author of the Book “Cults In Our Midst”, Margaret Thaler Singer writes, “The critical news is that you create everything. In short – you caused everything that has ever happened to you. Your loss of a job, your broken relationships, and your negative attitude – everything that you suffer from is your fault. You are responsible! Essentially, your life is not working and you need it fixed! The answer is always the same. The seminar is your answer to every problem you have ever faced”
- Clinical psychologist and former professor emeritus of the University of California – Berkeley, Author, Margaret Thaler Singer, (1921 – 2003), “Cults In Our Midst” (with Janja Lalich). In the 1960's Singer began to study the nature of cults and mind control and served on the board of the American Family Foundation. Dr. Singer's main areas of research included schizophrenia (reported nominated twice for the Nobel Prize for her work in schizophrenia), family therapy, brainwashing and coercive persuasion. She gave expert testimony in several cult-related trials, including the 1976 trial of Patty Hearst, who had previously been kidnapped by the Symbionese Liberation Army, and the 1977 hearing for five members of the Rev. Sun Myung Moon's Unification Church. Having interviewed more than 3,000 cult members, and assisted in over 200 court cases, Singer played a role in the trial of Kenneth Bianchi, in the “Hillside Strangler” case. Singer concluded that Bianchi had faked symptoms of multiple personality disorder, in order to escape responsibility for the murders of several women in Los Angeles. She was a guest on the PBS Frontline, speaking about the trial, in a special show entitled: “The Mind of a Murderer.” Singer asserted that Bianchi was a psychopath. Margret was a leading researcher in the field of psychosomatic medicine, and was made President of the American Psychosomatic Society in 1974, having been the first female president of the Society.
NUMEROUS AWARDS
Having served on President Gerald Ford's Biomedical Research Panel she has won numerous awards including the Leo J. Ryan Memorial Award, for research on cults, from the Citizens Freedom Foundation, Research Scientist Award from the National Institute of Mental Health, Hofheimer Prize, American College of Psychiatrists, 1966, Stanley R. Dean Award from the American College of Psychiatrists, Research in Schizophrenia, 1976, Achievement Awards – Mental Health Association of the United States, McAlpine Award for achievement in Research from the Mental Health Association of the United States, American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy Award for Cumulative contributions to Research in Family Therapy. In 2004, the international Cultic Studies Association created the “Margaret Singer Award” in her honor. The American Psychological Association (APA) in 1983 asked Singer, who was one of the leading proponents of coercive persuasion theories, to chair a task force to investigate whether brainwashing or “coercive persuasion” did indeed play a role in recruitment by such groups The task force was title APA Task Force On Deceptive and Indirect Techniques of Persuasion and Control (DIMPAC).
CONTROVERSIAL NEW AGE TRAINING COURSE - SINGER
In 1996, Landmark Education (an EST company), sued Singer for defamation. Singer mentioned Landmark Education in “Cults in our Midst; it was unclear whether she labeled Landmark Education as a cult or not. Amanda Scioscia, 2000, reported in the Phoenix New Times that Singer never called Landmark a cult, but that she described it as a “controversial New Age training course”. She also stated that she would not recommend the group to anyone, and would not comment on whether Landmark uses coercive persuasion for fear of legal recrimination from Landmark.
- Singer comments on Landmark, “I do not endorse them – never have”, in her 70's at the time, she said she can't comment on whether Landmark uses coercive persuasion because “the SOB's have already sued me once.” “I'm afraid to tell you what I really think about them because I'm not covered by any lawyers like I was when I wrote my book” - wikipedia.org
HOW DO CULTS INDOCTRINATE?
On March 22, 1997, Marshall Herff Applewhite and 37 of his disciples decided the time had come to shed their bodies – mere “containers” - and be whisked up to a UFO trailing the Hale-Bopp Comet, en route to heaven's gate. So they put themselves to sleep by mixing phenobarbital into pudding or applesauce, washing it down with vodka, and then fixing plastic bags over their heads so they would suffocate in their slumber.
On that same day, a cottage in French Canadian village of St. Casimir exploded in an inferno, consuming five people – the latest of 74 members of the Order of the Solar Temple to have committed suicide in Canada, Switzerland, and France. All were hoping to be transported to the star Sirius, nine light-years away.
Sun Myung Moon's mixture of Christianity, anticommunism, and glorification of Moon himself as a new messiah attracted a worldwide following. In response to Moon's declaration, “What I wish must be your wish,” many people committed themselves and their incomes to the Unification Church. In 1978 in Guyana, 914 disciples of Jim Jones, who had followed him there from San Francisco, shocked the world when they died by following his order to down a suicidal grape drink laced with tranquilizers, painkillers, and a lethal dose of cyanide.
In 1993, high-school dropout David Koresh used his talent for memorizing Scripture and mesmerizing people to seize control of a faction of a sect called the Branch Davidians. Over time, members were gradually relieved of their bank accounts and possessions. Koresh also persuaded the men to live celibately while he slept with their wives and daughters, and he convinced his 19 “wives” that they should bear his children.
Under siege after a shootout that killed six members and four federal agents, Koresh told his followers they would soon die and go with him straight to heaven. Federal agents rammed the compound with tanks, hoping to inject tear gas, and, by the end of the assault, 86 people were consumed in a fire that engulfed the compound. Why would people be persuaded by cults or organizations that employ brainwashing techniques? What must a person do to safe-guard themselves from such destructive programing? Reviewing social psychology research provides clues into cult phenomenon and the people who are attracted to the dynamics they employ.
ATTITUDES FOLLOW BEHAVIOR
- Deindividuation -Loss of self-awareness and evaluation apprehension; occurs in group situations that foster responsiveness to group norms, good or bad. Deindividuation can occur when one loses one's social identity and behaves in a manner in which one would not behave (Nelsen, 2005).
- Reward theory of attraction: The people who reward us, or who we associate with rewards, we like. This is especially true if the relationship is more profitable than alternative relationships (Burgess & Hudston, 1979; Kelly, 1979; Rusbult, 1980). We not only like people who are rewarding to be with; we also, according to the reward principle, like those we associate with good feelings. “If the cult and its trainer or charismatic leader provides you with the magical solution to your problems in life, you feel better about yourself, even if the solutions are a problem” - Synthia Esther. Theorists Donn Byrne and Gerald Clore – 1970, Albert Lott and Bernice Lott – 1974, Jan DeHouwer and colleagues – 2001, conditioning creates positive feelings toward things and people linked with rewarding events. Linking by association principle (Paul Lewicki, 1985).
- In everyday life people associate mostly with others whose attitudes are similar to their own. People also tend to select friends and marry those who are a good or equal match not only to their level of attractiveness (Bernard Murstein - 1986), but intelligence as well. Liking another person is greatly aided by similarity of attitudes, beliefs, and values. Cult members share the same cult experience, attitudes, beliefs, and values. A person's liking for another “does” predict the others liking in return (Kenny & Nasby, 1980).
- “Most of a person's everyday life is determined not by their conscious intentions and deliberate choices but by mental processes that are put into motion by features of the environment and that operate outside of conscious awareness and guidance” - John Bargh, Tanya Dhartrand (1999).
- Conformity grows if judgments are difficult or if the participants feel incompetent. The more insecure we are about our judgments, the more influenced we are by others. Someone who punctures a group's unanimity deflates its social power (Allen & Levine, 1969, Asch, 1955, Morris & Miller, 1975).
- Conformity is highest when a group has three or more people and is cohesive, unanimous, and high in status (conformity is played out in PSI/EST group games).
- Obedience, conformity, and conscious. Milgram (1965, 1974) experiments tested what happens when the demands of authority clash with the demands of conscience. Electrical shocks administered as explicitly commanded, succeeded in pressuring people to go against their own consciences. In the Milgram obedience experiments, a powerful social pressure (the experimenter's commands) overcame a weaker one (the remote victim's pleas). Torn between the pleas of the victim and the orders of the experimenter, between the desire to avoid doing harm and the desire to be a good participant, a surprising number of people chose to obey. Most cult members do the same, proving they are a good participant.
- People see not only what they expect, but also correlations they want to see – Illusory correlations. One of many research studies that prove this correlation exist was done by Mariette Berndsen and co-researchers (1996).
- Associating a message with good feelings makes it more convincing. People often make quick, less reflective judgments while in good moods. Emotionally packed messages that are vivid and arouse fear can also be effectively utilized, particularly if the participant can take protective action. Usually face to face appeals work best. By breaking you down, the cult trainer/leader than becomes the savior who builds you back up. As a means of self preservation you accept the savior and the message which makes you feel better. Then you celebrate your brainwashing in the happy, happy, joy, joy cult after party. Proverbs 19:2, “It is not good to have zeal without knowledge, nor to be hasty and miss the way.” God's Biblical knowledge leads to wisdom and understanding (Proverbs 2).
- Attitudes follow behavior. New recruits or converts soon learn that membership is a very serious privilege. Therefore they are encouraged to become active members of their new system of belief's by compiling to group norms and rituals. Bringing in new converts, family members and friends who can share in their new found cult experience. The more recruits and converts they bring into the organization the more they feel they belong, are accepted, and indeed “get it”. As those in social-psychological experiments come to believe in what they bear witness to (Aronson & Mills, 1959; Gerad & Mathewson, 1966), so cult initiates become committed advocates. The greater the personal commitment, the more the need to justify it. The more money is spent, the more the need to justify the spending. Cult members may state, “This experience changed my life!” The Bible states, only Jesus Christ can change a life!
- Emotionally packed messages as well as the warmth and acceptance the group showers lonely or depressed people can be profoundly appealing: *Trust the trainer, join the family; we have the answer, we know the way. This message is reinforced through participation in group activities, small group discussions, group exercises, or direct social pressure. Occult techniques such as visualization, subliminal indoctrination, hyper awareness, and hypnotism techniques are often utilized. *Authorities backed by institutions wield social power (Robert Ornstein, 1991).
- Trust is another aspect of credibility. Margaret Singer (1979) noted that middle-class Caucasian youths are more vulnerable to recruitment because they are more trusting. They lack the “street smarts” of lower-class youths (who know how to resist a hustle) and the wariness of upper-class youths (who have been warned of kidnappers since childhood). Many cult members have been recruited by friends or relatives, people they trust (Stark & Bainbridge, 1980).
- Higher status people tend to have more impact (Driskell & Mullen, 1990)
- Potential converts are often at turning points in their lives, facing personal problems or crises, vacationing or living away from home. They have needs; the cult offers them an answer (Singer, 1979, Lofland & Stark, 1965).
- The cult usually separates members from their previous social support systems, friends and family so as to isolate them with other cultists. Rodney Stark and William Bainbridge (1980) call this tactic “social implosion”. External ties weaken until the group collapses inward socially, each person engaging only with other group members. Cut off from families and former friends, they lose access to counterarguments. The group now offers identity and defines reality.
TACTICS FOR RESISTING INFLUENCE
1st Corinthians 15:33, Do not be misled: “Bad company corrupts good character.”
Ephesians 5:6-7, “Let no one deceive you with empty words, for because of such things God's wrath comes on those who are disobedient. (7) Therefore do not be partners with them.”
- Before encountering other personal opinions and judgments, make a public commitment to your position. By standing up for your convictions you are less likely to become susceptible or fall into temptation by exchanging your belief's for someone else's. In mock civil trails, straw polls of jurors can foster a hardening of expressed positions, leading to more deadlocks (Davis & Others, 1993). “The more you know what you stand for, the more difficult it is for another to cause you to doubt what you know.After several sessions during the seventh and eighth grades, the "inoculated" students were half as likely to begin smoking as were the "Un-inoculated" students at another junior high school that had an identical parental smoking rate.” - Synthia Esther
- Attitude inoculation – Exposing people to weak attacks and arguments pertaining to their attitudes and/or beliefs, so that when stronger attacks come, they will have refutations available (Jacks & Cameron, 2003). A research team led by Alfred McAlister (1980) had high school students “inoculate” seventh graders against peer pressures to smoke. The seventh graders were taught to respond to advertisements implying that liberated women smoke by saying, “She's not really liberated if she is hooked on tobacco.” They also acted in role plays in which, after being called “chicken” for not taking a cigarette, they answered with statements like, “I'd be a real chicken if I smoked just to impress you.” After several of these sessions during the seventh and eighth grades, the inoculated students were half as likely to begin smoking as were un-inoculated students at another junior high school that had an identical parental smoking rate.
- An attack or argument, if refuted, is more likely to solidify a person's position within a cult than to undermine it, particularly if the threatening material can be examined with like minded persons. Cults use this tactic by forewarning members of how families and friends will attack the cult's beliefs and doctrines. When the inevitable occurs the cult member is ready and able to counter argue. An ineffective unprepared appeal or persuasion can be worse than none because those who reject an appeal have been prepared and inoculated against most appeals.
- Proverbs 2:1-11, “My son, if you accept my words and store up my commands within you, turning your ear to wisdom and applying your heart to understanding, and if you call out for insight and cry aloud for understanding, and if you look for it as for silver and search for it as for hidden treasure, then you will understand the fear of the Lord and find the knowledge of God. For the Lord gives wisdom, and from his mouth come knowledge and understanding. He holds victory in store for the upright, he is a shield to those whose walk is blameless, for he guards the course of the just and protects the way of his faithful ones. Then you will understand what is right and just and fair – every good path. For wisdom will enter your heart, and knowledge will be pleasant to your soul. Discretion will protect you, and understanding will guard you.” It is the desire of Synthia Esther Ministries to lead the world to this profound Biblical truth. God's word is all the wisdom and understanding you will ever need or desire in life. By staying within the word of God you are planting His seed of success, victory, personal achievement, and power from on high within your heart, mind, and soul.
“ ALL THAT WE ARE IS A RESULT OF WHAT WE HAVE THOUGHT” - BUDDA
If this sounds familiar you may attribute these same sentiments to “The Secret Law Of Attraction” principles in the movie “The Secret” and book released by Australian author Rhonda Byrne. The movie claims in principal, like attracts like, choices both good and bad are fueled by our thoughts, everything that's coming into your life you are attracting etc. You are responsible for all that has happened in your life. Sounds like another documented quote from a PSI/EST seminar.
THE LAW OF ATTRACTION PRINCIPLES CAME THROUGH ESTHER HICKS WHO CHANNELS ENTITIES CALLED “ABRAHAM”
The law of attraction principles used within the movie “The Secret” came through spirit entities called “Abraham” channeled by Esther Hicks. The Abraham entities are referred to as “we are you in the future”. God finds such demonic/occult practices detestable (Deuteronomy 18:10-16). For additional information concerning “The Secret” with Biblical insights you can reference my article, “The Secret Law Of Attraction – A False Reality Of A Conceptual Manner.”
The Ankerberg Theological Research Institute, John Ankerburg's website has an excellent reference article under new age; Is “The Secret” compatible with Biblical Christianity? By staff correspondent A by ATRI, “Oprah guest and “Secret” promoter Michael Beckwith, founder and paster of Agape International Spiritual Center describes his theology as being in the “New Thought – Ancient Wisdom tradition of spirituality. Russ Wise suggests he is the most troubling of the Secret teachers “because he represents a pseudo – Christianity. He has the greatest ability to be used to deceive those whom God has touched by His Gospel.”
The article goes on to give comment to a question on “The Oprah Winfrey Show”, when an audience member asked a question about heaven and hell. Beckwith responded, “Jesus the Christ said the kingdom of heaven is within. He didn't say it was out there somewhere – he said within. And so is it possible to consider that the kingdom of hell is within as well?.. The kingdom of God is actually in us, and what comes out of your mouth, what you think about, how you express- you're either participating in the realm of ever-expanding good or you're cutting yourself off from the realm.”
James Swan of Alpha and Omega Ministries explains the problem with one part of Beckwith's answer. “Notice the context of the Biblical phrase kingdom of God was completely devoid from the answer. In Luke 17, the Pharisees wanted to know when the Kingdom would come. When would God's people see their prophesied theocratic leader? Certainly Jesus didn't believe God's kingdom was within these religious leaders. He considered them religious hypocrites.
In Romans 14:17, Paul states, “For the kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking, but of righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit, because anyone who serves God this way is pleasing to God and approved by men.” Jesus is actually rebuking the hypocrisy of the Pharisees, pointing out that the kingdom is an inner righteousness, not an outward righteousness of eating and drink, rules and regulations. We are given Christ's righteousness in justification. The Holy Spirit performs his work of sanctification, making our works pleasing to God.
The answer given by the Oprah show does more than misquote a Bible verse. It denies the Gospel.” The Gospel, as any careful reader will discern, is not the only Biblical doctrine or claim that is denied. In his review of “The Secret”, Donald Whitney says, “It is no exaggeration to say that this book implicitly (and sometimes explicitly) denies virtually every major doctrine in the Bible.” B.B. Warfild once said:
“He who begins by seeking God within himself may end up confusing himself as God”.
God puts it this way, “It is better to take refuge in the Lord than to trust in man” - Psalm 188:8.
Please Note:
Resources/information listed are provided as a public service. Synthia Esther Ministries does not endorse, sponsor, promote, or provide funding to, nor do we receive funding from any organization, group, website or persons listed. We are self funding, supported by personal donations to this ministry. To keep Synthia Esther Ministries website on the world wide web and support our global message of salvation and spiritual transformation through Jesus Christ, your donation and support is greatly needed and appreciated. For more information on how you can become an active part of our ministry team please click here.